23 Pizzerias In New York That Will Make You Say Mamma Mia

March 11, 2015

Share a slice of happiness to your travel buddies, with any of these remarkable pizzerias in New York!

New York, fittingly nicknamed as the foodie capital of the world, is bursting with world-class pizzerias that serve hearty and toothsome pies. From small joints with the quintessential New York slice to large chains serving one-of-a-kind varieties (like the deep-fried pizza), the options are practically endless, when it comes to pizzerias in New York. That’s why finding the best pizzerias in New York can be quite a tall order for anyone visiting “The Big Apple”.

Fortunately, we at Trekeffect will make things a lot easier on your end. After years of scouring the city’s streets and sampling a great deal of pies, we have come up with a list of the New York’s finest and most sought-after pizza joints. Here are the 25 pizzerias in New York that will make you say “mamma mia” or “delicioso”.

1. Joe’s Pizza

Start your trip to NYC with a blast by indulging on the meaty and filling classic New-York-style slice served at Joe’s Pizza in Carmine Street. For years, pizza freaks and food writers have raved about the joint’s scrumptious pizzas for its thin and crisp crust as well as it even layers of tomato sauce and cheese.

  • Address: 7 Carmine St, New York, New York, USA
  • Contact number: +1 212-366-1182

  • 2. Mario’s Restaurant

    Mario’s Restaurant is a charming and old-fashioned family-owned restaurant that will put you into a state of euphoria with its crisp and light pie covered in a fresh and distinctive tomato sauce.

  • Address: 2342 Arthur Avenue, Bronx, New York, USA
  • Contact number: +1 718-584-1188

  • 3. Lombardi’s Coal Oven Pizza

    Known as one of the best and oldest coal-oven pizzerias in New York, Lombardi’s Coal Oven Pizza is a blissful nirvana for foodies who are craving for authentic Napoletana pizzas.  Billing itself as the first pizzeria in America, the Lombardi’s Coal Oven Pizza is one of the pizzerias in New York that helped put pizza into the national limelight.

  • Address: 32 Spring Street, New York, New York, USA
  • Contact number: +1 212-941-7992

  • 4. New Park Pizzeria

    One of the oldest and most beloved pizzerias in New York, the New Park Pizzeria is a no-frills family-operated joint that has been serving great pizzas in their community for over 50 years. Simple yet adorable, this pizza joint will surely please your gusto with its appetizing authentic New York City slice.

    Baked in a traditional brick oven, their pizza’s crust certainly has more depth, in terms of flavor, than your typical slice.  Plus, each slice of pie in this joint is drench with a moderately sweet tomato sauce. Mamma mia!

  • Address: 15671 Cross Bay Boulevard, Jamaica, New York, USA
  • Contact number: +1 718-641-3082

  • 5. Louie & Ernie’s Pizza

    Swing by Louie & Ernie’s Pizza, and tickle your gusto their thin-crust gracefully topped pies. A customer’s favorite in this joint is the white pizza, but experts highly recommend their meaty sausage topped pie.

  • Address: 1300 Crosby Avenue, Bronx, New York, USA
  • Contact number: +1 718-829-6230

  • 6. Grimaldi’s Pizzeria

    In Grimaldi’s Pizzeria, not only will you get to enjoy a memorable slice of pie, but you’ll also get a breathtaking view of Manhattan from one of the most scenic parts of Brooklyn. Furthermore, it features a lovely jukebox brimming with timeless classics from the great Frank Sinatra, who, according to legend, had pies from Grimaldi’s Pizzeria flown to him in Las Vegas.

  • Address: 1 Front Street, Brooklyn, New York, USA
  • Contact number: +1 718-858-4300

  • 7. Roberta’s Pizza

    At Roberta’s Pizza, you get to gormandize on a yummy Neapolitan style pie with top-notch homemade mozzarella, locally grown vegetables and house-cured meats.

  • Address: 261 Moore Street, Brooklyn, New York, USA
  • Contact number: +1 718-417-1118

  • 8. Franny’s

    Every wood-fired rustic pie served at Franny’s is definitely worth a try. But to me, the can't-miss dish and standout in this cushy restaurant is the clam pie, which is quite possibly the best clam pizza in all of NYC.

  • Address: 348 Flatbush Avenue, Brooklyn, New York, USA
  • Contact number: +1 718-230-0221

  • 9. Joe and Pat’s Pizzeria

    With its super-thin extra-wide pizzas and freshly melted mozzarella, it’s no wonder pizza nerds deem Joe and Pat’s Pizzeria as one of the top pizzerias in New York.

  • Address: 1758 Victory Boulevard, Staten Island, New York, USA
  • Contact number: +1 718-981-0887

  • 10. John’s of Bleecker Street

    One of the oldest and most iconic pizzerias in New York, John’s of Bleecker Street is famous for its delicious pies that have light brown think crusts topped amply with cheese and sauce.  There is artfulness in its composition, but you don’t have to overly analyze its pizza to enjoy it. In fact, it just takes a single bite of their pizza, to know it’s filling and satisfying.

  • Address: 278 Bleecker Street, New York, New York, USA
  • Contact number: +1 212-243-1680

  • 11. L&B Spumoni Gardens

    L&B’s square slice tastes a bit different from the classic crispy corner slices and Neapolitan style pizzas of New York. Still, its unique pizza, with its sweet crust and rich mozzarella top, is adored by generations of New Yorkers. Besides its extraordinary pizza, L&B also boasts an atmospheric outdoor patio, making it one of the most charming pizzerias in New York.

  • Address: 2725 86th Street, Brooklyn, New York, USA
  • Contact number: +1 718-449-1230

  • 12. Original Pizza

    When visiting Original Pizza in Brooklyn, make sure try their Original Supreme, a delightful pie full of authentic ingredients, including fresh mozzarella, basil and a flavorful sauce.

  • Address: 2351 Ralph Avenue, Brooklyn, New York, USA
  • Contact number: +1 718-444-5007

  • 13. Paulie Gee’s

    Although they have mastered the art of baking and dough making, it is the toppings that make the pizzas of Paulie Gee’s so special. From freshly melted mozzarella and Amatriciana-style sauces to braised fennel fronds, they have a variety of toppings to make their pie an irresistible culinary treat.

  • Address: 60 Greenpoint Avenue, Brooklyn, New York, USA
  • Contact number: +1 347-987-3747

  • 14. Nunzio’s Pizzeria & Restaurant

    Nunzio’s Pizzeria & Restaurant, one of the historic pizzerias in New York, is a Staten Island joint that will give you a memorable gastronomic experience with its thick pizzas, square pieces as well as Neapolitan slices with a bevy of toppings.

  • Address: 2155 Hylan Boulevard, State Island, New York, USA
  • Contact number: +1 718-667-9647

  • 15. Trattoria Zero Otto Nove

    Upscale and yet casual, Trattoria Zero Otto Nove is a brightly lit and atmospheric pizzeria that will gratify your taste senses with its fine pizza combination of fresh mozzarella, chewy crust and delicious sopressata. Delicioso!

  • Address: 2357 Arthur Avenue, Bronx, New York, USA
  • Contact number: +1 718-220-1027

  • 16. Mariella Pizza

    Get a pleasant taste of Italy by devouring on the piquant New York style pizza of Mariella Pizza. By the way, Mariella Pizza is one of the pizzerias in New York that Oprah Winfrey loves.

  • Address: 180 3rd Avenue, New York, New York, USA
  • Contact number: +1 212-777-1322

  • 17. Artichoke Basille’s Pizza & Brewery

    For the past ten years, Artichoke Basille’s Pizza & Brewery has been appeasing nomadic foodies and New Yorkers with its iconic pizza treats. Their signature dish, the Artichoke pizza, may not be everyone’s favorite, but it has a supremely thick crust with a tasty dip that will surely please your gastronomic urges.

    For those aren’t overly fond of thick crusts, Artichoke offers a superb alternative in the Sicilian slice. With its pliant mozzarella crown and crispy edges, the Sicilian slice truly makes an irresistible mouthwatering pie even for pizza purists. What’s more, this pizzeria has a load of other tasty pizza goodies on their menu, such as the Meatball Parm, Burnt Anchovy, Margherita, and Staten Island.

  • Address: 328 E 14th Street, New York, New York, USA
  • Contact number +1 212-228-2004

  • 18. Lucali

    Unlike most top restaurants and pizzerias in New York, Lucali is pretty limited, when it comes to menu, serving only calzones and pizza. In addition, its floor space is relatively tight and small, which usually is a turn-off for New Yorkers.

    Yet surprisingly, a lot of people in NYC are drawn to this pizzeria. As a matter of fact, most of them would wait for an hour in a long queue every day, just to get a taste of its pizzas and calzones. What’s even more remarkable is the fact that its lures tons of famous A-listers like Jay-Z and Beyonce.

    Is it worth the wait? Trust me, their pizzas are something to die for.

  • Address: 575 Henry Street, Brooklyn, New York, USA
  • Contact number: +1 718-858-4086

  • 19. Co.

    With its fresh toppings, blistered edges and scrumptious chewy crusts, it’s easy to see why New Yorkers consider Co as one of the finest pizzerias in New York today. A must-try in this pizza parlor is the Popeye, an ultra delicious pie topped with a healthy serving of spinach. Likewise, you might want to try their cauliflower pie and flambé pizza.

  • Address: 230 9th Avenue, New York, NY, USA
  • Contact number: +1 212-243-1105

  • 20. Ribalta

    As a guest in Ribalta, you have a wide array of innovative, traditional and even gluten-free choices that are all cooked from a classic wood-burning oven.

  • Address: 48 E 12th Street, New York, New York, USA
  • Contact number: +1 212-777-7781

  • 21. Di Fara Pizza

    No list of the best pizzerias in New York is complete without the inclusion of Di Fara Pizza. After all, it is a highly acclaimed pie joint that has been tagged as the home of the “Best Pizza in NYC” on numerous occasions by dozens of publications, including Serious Eats, Frommer’s and Zagats. Not to mention, its tasty pies were once labeled as “the best of the best” by the renowned celebrity chef Anthony Bourdain.

    Did I mention that Di Fara is owned and operated by Dom DeMarco, a legendary pizzaiolo and a local celebrity?

  • Address: 1424 Avenue J, Brooklyn, New York, USA
  • Contact number: +1 718-258-1367

  • 22. Motorino

    Mathieu Palombino and the rest of the Motorino team have been getting tons of praises, thanks to their filling, fluffy and tasteful Neapolitan-style pies. As far as I’m concerned, the pizzeria’s soppresata pizza and Brussels sprouts pie are appetizing goodies that every tourist in New York should try.

  • Address: 139 Broadway, Brooklyn, New York, USA
  • Contact number: +1 718-599-8899

  • 23. Lee’s Tavern

    While Lee’s Tavern isn’t as popular as Di Fara and Lucali, this quaint State Island pizzeria has a fiercely loyal following that will defend the pub’s crisp bar pizzas. In addition to its top-notch pies, the place is a great and cozy place to drink a pint of beer.

  • Address: 60 Hancock Street, Staten Island, New York, USA
  • Contact number: +1 718-667-9749

  • Having some problems planning the ultimate vacation to New York? Make things a whole lot simpler and easier on your end, by grabbing a copy of this detailed New York travel itinerary!

    Book Your Trip: Logistical Tips & Tricks

    Book your accommodations

    Let's face it.  Expedia, hotels.com (and all the other hotel booking engines) typically earn huge margins off of you.  You might think you're getting a deal, but you're not getting a deal.  Want the best deal when you book your hotels?   Of course you do! With Trekeffect you can get FREE access to discounted hotel prices and save a bunch of money.  

    How does it work? Simple... 
    1. Sign up for Trekeffect [FREE]
    2. Click the hotels tab in the navigation
    3. Search for the city you are visiting
    4. Book a hotel and save a ton of money

    Shop for Travel Essentials

    Get all of your essential travel gear right from our store. We hand pick the best travel products. Get everything from luggage to camping gear and other travel accessories for your trip. 

    Book your flight

    Find cheap flights using SkyScanner. This search engine is are our favorite, making sure you get the best deal for tickets all over the world.  They are great at aggregating flights from multiple providers.  

    Don't forget travel insurance

    Protects yourself against illness, injury, theft, and even cancellations with travel insurance. You're buying comprehensive protection in case anything goes wrong. We never recommend traveling without it. We’ve been using World Nomads, a great company, with great service and highly recommend them.

         - World Nomads (for everyone below 70)

         - Travelx Insurance (for those over 70)

    Looking for the best companies to save money with?

    Check out our resource page for the absolute best companies to use when you travel! We list our favorite companies that save people the most money when they travel and we think it will help you too!

    Disclosure: Some of the links above may be affiliate links, and at no additional cost to you, we earn a commission if you make a purchase. We only recommend products and companies we use and the income keeps the community supported. 

    Alternative Text
    Ashley Thompson
    A fun size lass born in rock and roll who dreams to become a rock star, or a world traveler, or both.
    Trekeffect Hotel Booking Engine
    Cheap & Luxurious Hotels From Around The World
    Compare hotel prices in a fast & simple way. Book your ideal hotel. Get last minute deals and high-class service guaranteed.